Author: Azadeh Haidari-Garmash, RCIC
Canadian Sentiments on Immigration: A Growing Concern
A recent survey by the Canadian Museum for Human Rights reveals an increasing unease among Canadians regarding immigration and its perceived role in creating "economic strain."
Survey Findings
The survey highlights a burgeoning belief that excessive attention is directed toward newcomers and refugees, with many Canadians feeling that asylum seekers receive disproportionate benefits. Conducted with 2,500 participants in both 2023 and 2024, the survey reports a rise from 49% to 56% in those who say refugees and asylum seekers "receive too many benefits."
Moreover, there's a notable decline in those who view immigration positively; only 44% now believe it improves the country, down from 52% in 2023. Additionally, 41% of respondents feel there's "too much attention focused on the rights of newcomers."
Broader Context and Reactions
The survey's release coincides with recent announcements from Ottawa regarding changes to immigration targets, with Prime Minister Justin Trudeau acknowledging a need for swifter action to address systemic issues. In a video statement, Trudeau attributed some challenges to "bad actors" within the immigration system.
The response from advocacy groups has been swift and critical. The Migrant Rights Network condemned Trudeau's remarks, accusing him of perpetuating harmful myths and diverting attention from policy failures. They advocate for permanent residency status for all migrants, emphasizing their essential contributions to Canada's economy and society.
Broader Human Rights Concerns
The survey, part of the 2024 Foresights for Human Rights report, also explored other human rights issues. Only 11% of respondents identified affordable housing as a primary concern, yet nearly 60% believe the right to housing has weakened over the past decade.
Interestingly, while two-thirds of participants expressed optimism about domestic human rights, particularly regarding Indigenous rights and gender equity, only one-third felt similarly about international human rights.
A Call for Deeper Understanding
Isha Khan, CEO of the Canadian Museum for Human Rights, stresses the need for further investigation into the changing perceptions of immigration, where these perceptions originate and how they influence our collective efforts.
As the conversation surrounding immigration continues to evolve, it becomes increasingly critical to balance policy reform with the narratives shaping public opinion. The dialogue remains ongoing, with stakeholders from all sides urging a more nuanced and informed approach to immigration and human rights in Canada.
